8. Conclusions
8.1 We now try to draw together the key elements of the discussion. The
Committee suggests that decisions on user charges for publicly funded
museums, galleries and national parks need to consider the following hierarchy
of questions:
8.2 1. Are there powerful emotional or symbolic reasons why access ought
to be free of charge, as a fundamental value statement? (chapter
4)
8.3 It may be argued that free entry powerfully symbolises the fact that
the value of these places is not measured in money. It may be argued that
imposing charges, however little, is objectionable in principle because
it degrades the community standing of the place as a public institution
and changes us, when we visit, from citizens to customers (paragraph 4.45ff).
A prime case was the community outrage at the imposition of entry fees
in the museum galleries of the Australian War Memorial in 1991. The question
may be posed separately in respect of entry fees and charges for value-added
services, and the answer may well be that entry ought to be free while
extras may be charged for. [1]
8.4 If a proposal to impose charges passes this hurdle, the next question
is:
8.5 2. If an entry fee is not objectionable for fundamental symbolic
reasons, is it still objectionable because it excessively discourages
use (particularly by poorer or disadvantaged people (chapters
5 and 6)
8.6 This question refers to the discussion of elasticity of demand: how
much does an entry fee discourage visitors? Museums, galleries and national
parks are (in respect of most of their benefits) textbook `public goods':
where demand is elastic, discouraged would-be visitors represents a deadweight
loss of benefit to the community as a whole which is not compensated by
reduction in running costs (see paragraph 5.15ff). The deadweight loss
is an unavoidable consequence of any public policy decision to throw some
of the cost burden of a non-rival public good onto direct users. If the
deadweight loss is significant the policy is misguided. As well (particularly
in relation to museums and galleries), there is the possibility that the
discouraged visitors may be disproportionately people of lower socio-economic
status who (as all submissions agreed) managers should be making special
efforts to attract.
8.7 3. If an entry fee/ user charge is still under consideration, how
can it be implemented so as not to inhibit wide access, and to minimise
the risk of diverting management from core missions?
8.8 In the Committee's opinion the answers to these questions are, in
summary:
Conclusions on museums and art galleries
8.9 1. There are powerful emotional and symbolic reasons
why access to education and cultural enrichment through museums and galleries
should be free of charge. Charging entry fees does change the relationship
between the institution and the public. The change from a community resource
serving us as citizens to just another business serving us as customers.
This is regrettable, and threatens longer term public support for the
institution (as well as putting at risk other benefits such as volunteerism
and sponsorship). Accordingly the Committee believes that entry to key
national and state cultural institutions should be free.
8.10 2. Based on the evidence of the inquiry, it appears that
imposing entry fees in museums and art galleries significantly discourages
visitation and so causes a deadweight loss of community welfare which
is regrettable. As well, it probably accentuates the upper-class bias
among visitors, working against museums' access and equity programs. This
is most regrettable.
8.11 A general application of the philosophical position that `users
should pay for private benefits' is not appropriate: the rational
course is to consider the likely effects case by case. Wherever entry
fees significantly discourage visitation entry should be free (or fees
held at a level which does not discourage visitation) on purely
economic grounds whether or not it is also suggested for symbolic `citizenship'
reasons. This would probably extend the desirable scope of free entry
a good way beyond the `key national and state institutions' mentioned
above. Where entry fees do not significantly discourage visitation (demand
is inelastic) they are not objectionable on grounds of economic efficiency
or equity, though they may still be objectionable for symbolic reasons
depending on the case.
8.12 3. In cases that have passed the first two hurdles, entry
fees and/or user charges for value-added services are acceptable providing
they are managed so as to maintain wide access and to minimise the undoubted
risk of distracting managers from their core mission of conserving our
heritage for public enjoyment and for future generations. The main conditions
suggested by these principles are:
1. It must be accepted that user charges can usually raise no more
than a small percentage of total costs. Budget funding for these public
institutions should ensure that total funding is appropriate to management
needs; it should not be tied to user charges revenue as a reward or punishment
for high or low revenue-raising.
2. Charges for non-commercial use of value-added services
should generally be based on no more than marginal cost recovery: budgets
must acknowledge that the fixed costs of maintaining the resource for
future generations are a charge on the whole community.
3. For commercial users higher charges are acceptable (whether
entry fees or value-added charges) to the extent of a fair contribution
towards maintaining the resource from which they draw profit.
4. There should be suitable concessions for access and equity purposes.
5. Revenue should be retained locally to improve management.
6.There must be orderly, open and consultative strategic planning
to allow informed community input to future directions for management
and to avoid the tyranny of little decisions.
Conclusions on national parks
8.13 1. Emotional and symbolic arguments for free entry can be
raised for national parks as for museums and galleries. Outdoor temples
house the wonders of nature, and we may hope that visitors' experience
of them is something deeper and more lasting than mere `recreational use.'
For many people this spiritual dimension warrants free entry to national
parks as surely as it does to churches. As well, we acknowledge the `strong
Australian cultural tradition of free public access to public lands.'
[2]
8.14 Nevertheless, the Committee refrains from making a recommendation
on free entry corresponding to that for museums and galleries just above.
To suggest a category of `key' national parks creates too many difficulties.
With national parks there is no obvious `first eleven': the circumstances
of individual parks are too varied. To define `key ` national parks in
terms of nature conservation may seem to undermine the goal of having
a comprehensive and representative reserve system. To define them in terms
of public recreation would suggest that `key' national parks are the most
popular ones; but the most popular national parks are the very ones where,
on economic and equity grounds, entry fees are least objectionable
(see chapters 5 and 6). Entry
fee policies for national parks need to be decided on a case by case basis.
8.15 2. The extent to which entry fees discourage national park
visitation is uncertain, and the situation probably varies greatly from
one national park to another. However the same principle applies: where
fees do significantly discourage visitation, entry should be free (or
at least limited to covering marginal costs) on grounds of economic efficiency.
8.16 3. In cases that have passed the first two hurdles, entry
fees and/or user charges for value-added services are acceptable providing
they are managed so as to maintain wide access and to minimise the undoubted
risk of distracting managers from their core mission of conserving our
heritage for public enjoyment and for future generations. The main conditions
suggested by these principles are:
1. It must be accepted that user charges can usually raise no more
than a small percentage of total costs. Budget funding for these public
institutions should ensure that total funding is appropriate to management
needs; it should not be tied to user charges revenue as a reward or punishment
for high or low revenue-raising.
2. Where there is a non-trivial elasticity of demand (discouraged
visitors), suggesting that entry should be free, free entry must be retained
as a real option: charges for value-added services must not become a proxy
for entry fees.
3. Charges for non-commercial use of value-added services
should generally be based on no more than marginal cost recovery: budgets
must acknowledge that the fixed costs of maintaining the resource for
future generations are a charge on the whole community.
4. For commercial users higher charges are acceptable (whether
entry fees or value-added charges) to the extent of a fair contribution
towards maintaining the resource from which they draw profit.
5. There should be suitable concessions for access and equity purposes.
6. Revenue should be retained locally to improve management.
7. Commercial development inside national parks should be discouraged
to prevent the creation of a cycle of dependence.
8. There must be orderly, open and consultative strategic planning
to allow informed community input to future directions for management
and to avoid the tyranny of little decisions.
Footnotes
[1] For example, the Australian War Memorial
abandoned the entry fee to its museum galleries because of public protest;
but it does charge for various value-added services without controversy.
Australian War Memorial, submission 23 p204
[2] Environment Australia, submission 46 p397
In this section
Senate CommitteesMaking a submissionAttending a public hearingSenate committee activityAppropriations, Staffing and SecurityCommunity AffairsEconomicsEducation and EmploymentEnvironment and CommunicationsAdditional Estimates 2024-25Annual Reports (No. 1 of 2025)Annual ReportsAnnual reports (No. 1 of 2024)Annual Reports (No. 2 of 2024)Upcoming HearingsCompleted inquiries and reportsAdditional Estimates 2023-24Budget Estimates 2024-25Recent reportsNational Broadband Network Companies Amendment (Commitment to Public Ownership) Bill 2024 [Provisions]Offshore wind industry consultation processProtecting the Spirit of Sea Country Bill 2023Waste reduction and recycling policiesGreenwashingAustralia's extinction crisisNational Cultural PolicyEnvironment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Amendment (Reconsideration of Decisions) Bill 2024 Future Made in Australia (Guarantee of Origin) Bill 2024 [Provisions] and related billsCommunications Legislation Amendment (Combatting Misinformation and Disinformation) Bill 2024 [Provisions]Murdoch Media Inquiry Bill 2023Online Safety Amendment (Social Media Minimum Age) Bill 2024 [Provisions]Optus Network OutageEnvironment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Amendment (Save the Koala) Bill 2021Nature Positive (Environment Protection Australia) Bill 2024 [Provisions] and related billsLapsed inquiriesCommunications Legislation Amendment (Regional Broadcasting Continuity) Bill 2024Middle Arm Industrial PrecinctGlencore’s proposed carbon capture and storage projectClimate Change Amendment (Duty of Care and Intergenerational Climate Equity) Bill 2023Australian Antarctic Division fundingCommunications Legislation Amendment (Prominence and Anti-siphoning) Bill 2023 [Provisions]Telecommunications Legislation Amendment (Enhancing Consumer Safeguards and Other Measures) Bill 2023 [Provisions]Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Amendment (Climate Trigger) Bill 2022Climate-related marine invasive speciesProgress ReportImpacts and management of feral horses in the Australian AlpsInteractive Gambling Amendment (Credit and Other Measures) Bill 2023 [Provisions]Water Amendment (Restoring Our Rivers) Bill 2023 [Provisions]Nature Repair Market Bill 2023 and Nature Repair Market (Consequential Amendments) Bill 2023 [Provisions]Annual Reports (No. 1 of 2023)Annual reports (No. 2 of 2023)Budget Estimates 2023-24Greenhouse and Energy Minimum Standards Amendment (Administrative Changes) Bill 2023Climate Change Bill 2022 and the Climate Change (Consequential Amendments) Bill 2022Environment and Other Legislation Amendment (Removing Nuclear Energy Prohibitions) Bill 2022Environment Protection (Sea Dumping) Amendment (Using New Technologies to Fight Climate Change) Bill 2023 [Provisions]Excise Tariff Amendment (Product Stewardship for Oil) Bill 2023 [Provisions] and Customs Tariff Amendment (Product Stewardship for Oil) Bill 2023 [Provisions]Offshore Electricity Infrastructure Legislation Amendment Bill 2022 [Provisions]Oil and gas exploration and production in the Beetaloo Basin Safeguard Mechanism (Crediting) Amendment Bill 2022 [Provisions]Telecommunications Legislation Amendment (Information Disclosure, National Interest and Other Measures) Bill 2022 [Provisions]Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Amendment (Save the Koala) Bill 2021Australia’s faunal extinction crisisOil and gas exploration and production in the Beetaloo BasinEnvironment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Amendment (Climate Trigger) Bill 2020ABC and SBS complaints handlingAustralia Post inquiryBroadcasting Legislation Amendment (2021 Measures No.1) Bill 2021Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Amendment (Regional Forest Agreements) Bill 2020Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Amendment (Standards and Assurance) Bill 2021Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Amendment (Streamlining Environmental Approvals) Bill 2020Competition and Consumer Amendment (Prevention of Exploitation of Indigenous Cultural Expressions) Bill 2019Coal-Fired Power Funding Prohibition Bill 2017The future of Australia Post’s service deliveryGrid Reliability Fund Bill 2020Hazardous Waste (Regulation of Exports and Imports) Amendment Bill 2021Impact of feral deer, pigs and goats in AustraliaImpact of seismic testing on fisheries and the marine environmentIndustrial Chemicals Environmental Management (Register) Bills 2020Interactive Gambling Amendment (Prohibition on Credit Card Use) Bill 2020Live Performance Federal Insurance Guarantee Fund Bill 2021Media diversity in AustraliaMurray-Darling Basin Commission of Inquiry Bill 2019National Collecting Institutions Legislation Amendment Bill 2020Offshore Electricity Infrastructure (Regulatory Levies) Bill 2021 and Offshore Electricity Infrastructure Bill 2021Online Safety BillPress FreedomProduct Stewardship Amendment (Packaging and Plastics) Bill 2019Product Stewardship (Oil) Amendment Bill 2020 and the Excise Tariff Amendment Bill 2020 Radiocommunications Bills 2020The impact of feral deer, pigs and goats in AustraliaRecycling and Waste Bills 2020Telecommunications Legislation Amendment (Competition and Consumer) Bill 2019 and the Telecommunications (Regional Broadband Scheme) Charge Bill 2019Telecommunications Legislation Amendment (Unsolicited Communications) Bill 2019Telstra Corporation and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2021Treasury Laws Amendment (2021 Measures No. 5) Bill 2021Australia’s faunal extinction crisisAustralian content on broadcast, radio and streaming servicesGaming micro-transactions for chance-based items Great Barrier Reef 2050 Partnership ProgramRehabilitation of mining and resources projects as it relates to Commonwealth responsibilitiesWater use by the extractive industryTreasury Laws Amendment (Improving the Energy Efficiency of Rental Properties) Bill 2018Telecommunications Legislation Amendment Bill 2018Water Amendment (Purchase Limit Repeal) Bill 2019Copyright Amendment (Online Infringement) Bill 2018Galilee Basin (Coal Prohibition) Bill 2018Environment Legislation Amendment (Protecting Dugongs and Turtles) Bill 2019The allegations of political interference in the Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC)Current and future impacts of climate change on housing, buildings and infrastructureClean Energy Finance Corporation Amendment (Carbon Capture and Storage) Bill 2017 [Provisions]National Broadcasters Legislation Amendment (Enhanced Transparency) Bill 2017Copyright Amendment (Service Providers) Bill 2017Australian Broadcasting Corporation Amendment (Fair and Balanced) Bill 2017Australian Broadcasting Corporation Amendment (Rural and Regional Measures) Bill 2017Communications Legislation Amendment (Regional and Small Publishers Innovation Fund) Bill 2017Communications Legislation Amendment (Online Content Services and Other Measures) Bill 2017Competition and Consumer Amendment (Abolition of Limited Merits Review) Bill 2017Environment and Infrastructure Legislation Amendment (Stop Adani) Bill 2017Telecommunications Legislation Amendment (Competition and Consumer) Bill 2017 [Provisions] and Telecommunications (Regional Broadband Scheme) Charge Bill 2017 [Provisions]Australian Broadcasting Corporation Amendment (Restoring Shortwave Radio) Bill 2017Carbon Credits (Carbon Farming Initiative) Amendment Bill 2017 [Provisions]Australian Broadcasting Corporation Amendment (Rural and Regional Advocacy) Bill 2015Great Australian Bight Environment Protection Bill 2016 Interactive Gambling Amendment (Sports Betting Reform) Bill 2015Environmental, social and economic impacts of large-capacity fishing vessels commonly known as 'Supertrawlers' operating in Australia's Marine JurisdictionInteractive Gambling Amendment Bill 2016 [Provisions]Response to, and lessons learnt from, recent bushfires in remote Tasmanian wildernessBroadcasting Legislation Amendment (Media Reform Bill) 2016 [Provisions]Risks and opportunities associated with the use of the bumblebee population in Tasmania for commercial pollination purposesWaste and recycling industry in AustraliaAustralian Broadcasting Corporation Amendment (Rural and Regional Advocacy) Bill 2015Protection of Aboriginal rock art of the Burrup PeninsulaShark mitigation and deterrent measuresInteractive Gambling Amendment (Sports Betting Reform) Bill 2015Current and future impacts of climate change on marine fisheries and biodiversityHarm being done to Australian children through access to pornography on the InternetParticipation of Australians in online pokerRisks and opportunities associated with the use of the bumblebee population in Tasmania for commercial pollination purposesOil or gas production in the Great Australian BightRetirement of coal fired power stationsContinuation of construction of the Perth Freight Link in the face of significant environmental breachesResponses to, and lessons learnt from, the January and February 2016 bushfires in remote Tasmanian wildernessEnvironmental, social and economic impacts of large-capacity fishing vessels commonly known as 'Supertrawlers' operating in Australia's marine jurisdictionHarm being done to Australian children through access to pornography on the InternetOil or Gas Production in the Great Australian BightEnvironmental, social and economic impacts of large-capacity fishing vessels commonly known as 'Supertrawlers' operating in Australia's Marine JurisdictionTelecommunications Legislation Amendment (Access Regime and NBN Companies) Bill 2015Broadcasting Legislation Amendment (Media Reform Bill) 2016 [Provisions]Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Amendment (Prohibition of Live Imports of Primates for Research) Bill 2015The threat of marine plastic pollution in AustraliaFuture of Australia's video game development industryWater Amendment Bill 2015 [Provisions]Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Amendment (Standing) Bill 2015Motor Vehicle Standards (Cheaper Transport) Bill 2014StormwaterThe performance and management of electricity network companiesAustralia's environmentCommunications Legislation Amendment (SBS Advertising Flexibility and Other Measures) Bill 2015 [Provisions]Environmental BiosecurityAustralian Broadcasting Corporation Amendment (Local Content) Bill 2014Enhancing Online Safety for Children Bill 2014 [Provisions] and the Enhancing Online Safety for Children ( Consequential Amendments) Bill 2014 [Provisions]National Landcare ProgramTelecommunications Legislation Amendment (Deregulation) Bill 2014 and Telecommunications (Industry Levy) Amendment Bill 2014 [Provisions]National Water Commission (Abolition) Bill 2014Performance, importance and role of Australia Post in Australian communities and its operations in relation to licensed post officesNational Broadband Network Companies Amendment (Tasmania) Bill 2014Climate Change Authority (Abolition) Bill 2013 [No. 2]Clean Energy Legislation (Carbon Tax Repeal) Bill 2013 No. 2 and related billsCarbon Farming Initiative Amendment Bill 2014 [Provisions]Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Amendment (Bilateral Agreement Implementation) Bill 2014 [Provisions] and the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Amendment (Cost Recovery) Bill 2014 [Provisions]Telecommunications Legislation Amendment (Submarine Cable Protection) Bill 2013Environment Legislation Amendment Bill 2013Parliamentary Proceedings Broadcasting Amendment Bill 2013Clean Energy Legislation (Carbon Tax Repeal) Bill 2013 [Provisions] and related billsGreat Barrier ReefInquiry into Environmental OffsetsTasmanian Wilderness World Heritage AreaCopyright Legislation Amendment (Fair Go for Fair Use) Bill 2013 Finance and Public AdministrationForeign Affairs, Defence and TradeLegal and Constitutional AffairsMeasuring Outcomes for First Nations CommunitiesPFAS (per and polyfluoroalkyl substances)PrivilegesProcedurePublicationsRural and Regional Affairs and TransportScrutiny of BillsScrutiny of Delegated LegislationSelection of BillsSenators' InterestsSenate committee evidence, parliamentary privilege and Royal CommissionsSenate Committee MembershipSenate Committees: Upcoming Public HearingsToday's public hearingsRecent Senate Committee reportsFormer Senate CommitteesGovernment responses outstanding to committee reports
Top
|