Chapter 2

29th Report of the Senate Select Committee on Superannuation
Commonwealth Superannuation Bills
Table of Contents

Chapter 2

The Bills

Superannuation Legislation (Commonwealth Employment) Repeal and Amendment Bill 1997

2.1 The Government has stated that the main purpose of the Bill is to allow Commonwealth employees to participate in the Government's choice of funds arrangements that are proposed in the Taxation Laws Amendment Bill (No.7) 1997 as announced in the 1997 Budget. According to the government this will provide Commonwealth employees with greater choice, flexibility and control over their superannuation arrangements. [1]

2.2 The PSS will be closed to new members from 1 July 1998 although active PSS membership may still be available for new employees who left the PSS before that date and have a PSS preserved benefit (similar arrangements may apply for new employees who have CSS preserved benefits).

2.3 Consequent to the closure of the PSS, Commonwealth departments and agencies will be required to offer new employees a choice of fund in accordance with the Government's Choice of Fund legislation.

2.4 From 1 July 2000, departments and agencies will be required to also offer choice to continuing CSS and PSS members. CSS and PSS members will have the choice of remaining in their scheme, with no change to existing arrangements, or ceasing membership with future employer superannuation paid to a superannuation fund or RSA offered to them by their employer. The entitlements for members who exercise choice have been designed to ensure no increase in unfunded liabilities.

2.5 Each Commonwealth Department and agency will be responsible for selecting complying superannuation funds and Retirement Saving Accounts (RSAs) (including the default fund) to be offered to their employees.

2.6 Departments or agencies must provide for a default fund regardless of which choice arrangement they provide to their employees. If employees do not make a choice within 28 days of commencing duty they are automatically placed in the default fund.

2.7 Department and agencies must provide at least minimum superannuation guarantee contributions for future employees. In respect of existing employees, saving provisions will require that the employer continue the higher rate for the duration of that employment to ensure employees are not disadvantaged by the new arrangements.

2.8 Consistent with the Government's choice of fund legislation, Commonwealth employers and employees will also have the option of using workplace agreements to specify superannuation arrangements. Workplace agreements cannot be used to require a member to cease CSS or PSS membership or to tie them to the CSS/PSS after 30 June 2000.

2.9 From 1 July 1998, the Superannuation (Productivity Benefit) Act 1988 (PB Act) will be repealed. As a result the Australian Government Employees Superannuation Trust (AGEST) will continue to remain open to existing and new members, but will cease to be the legislated default fund for new employees.

2.10 The Bill also includes a number of other changes. These are:

2.11 The Bill also proposes a number of minor amendments to the Parliamentary Contributory Superannuation Act. These are:

i) Changes to access to spouse benefits where a retiring member, entitled to a pension, commenced a post-retirement martial relationship after age 60;

ii) The payment of transfer values by new members of Parliament; and

iii) Other minor technical matters, including the payment of orphan benefits.

Financial Implications

2.12 There are three elements in the Bill that have financial implications. These relate to post retirement reversionary benefits, the full funding of future benefit accruals for new employees and those CSS and PSS members who exercise choice and CSS late elections for preservation.

2.13 The changes to post retirement reversionary benefit arrangements are estimated to increase outlays by $2.2 million per year. The increased outlays arise from the expected increase in the number of reversionary benefits that will be paid under the changed arrangements.

2.14 The Bill will result in the funding of future superannuation accruals for new employees and for existing CSS and PSS members who elect to join another complying superannuation fund or Retirement Savings Account. The estimated additional outlays over the next three years are $12 million in 1998-99, $40 million in 1999-00 and $290 million in 2000-01. However, these increased cash flows do not represent any additional expense; they in effect bring forward future cash flows in lieu of an increase in unfunded liabilities.

2.15 Both the CSS and PSS are defined benefit schemes, which means they are partly unfunded. The employee benefits are funded when they become payable rather when the benefits accrue to them, resulting in the accumulation of unfunded liabilities. As at 30 June 1997 the unfunded liability of the CSS and PSS was $42.5 billion, with $15 billion of this amount relating to current CSS and PSS members.

2.16 The government estimates that the closure of the PSS will result, over the long term, in a decrease in the Commonwealth's level of unfunded liabilities.

2.17 The amendments to restore the intention of the Superannuation Act 1976 in relation to late elections for preservation are expected to avoid a potential increase on outlays of around $10 million per year.

2.18 Departments and budget funded agencies are currently funded at the existing rates for the CSS (21.9% of salaries) and the PSS (13.1% of salaries). Funding for superannuation is a component of running costs or budget appropriation and will be updated by the same indexation process as for other labour costs.

2.19 According to the Department of Finance and Administration (DoFA) there will be no change in funding levels for departments and agencies for employer superannuation payments. However employees will be free to negotiate with their employers whether all of this funding is paid in the form of superannuation contributions or a proportion is paid as enhancements to other employment conditions. The employer is required to have superannuation provided at the Superannuation Guarantee safety net rate for all employees as a minimum. From 1998/99 the rate is 7% increasing to 9% from 2002/03. [2]

Commonwealth Superannuation Board Bill 1997

2.20 This Bill will establish a new Commonwealth Superannuation Board to administer the closed Commonwealth superannuation schemes for current and former employees. It will take over the responsibility of the CSS Board and PSS Board and the Commissioner for Superannuation.

2.21 The board will comprise an independent Chair appointed by the Minister for Finance and Administration after consultation with other Board members, and an equal number of member and employer representatives. Scheme members will elect member representatives.

Superannuation Legislation (Commonwealth Employment – Saving and Transitional Provisions) Bill 1997

2.22 This Bill will put in place saving and transitional provisions as a consequence of certain amendments to the Superannuation Act 1976 and the subsequent repeal of the Superannuation Act 1976, Superannuation Act 1990, Superannuation Act 1922, and Superannuation (Productivity Benefit) Act 1988.

2.23 However, in most circumstances, the repeal legislation will continue to operate through the application of this Bill, thus preserving the benefits currently available to members of the various Commonwealth superannuation schemes. The Minister for Finance and Administration or the new CS Board will be able to amend the repealed legislation by disallowable instrument.

Footnotes

[1] Explanatory Memorandum, Superannuation Legislation (Commonwealth Employment) Repeal and Amendment Bill 1997.

[2] Submission, Department of Finance and Administration Submission, p. 11.