House of Representatives Committees

Standing Committee on Economics, Finance and Public Administration

Review of the ANAO audit report No.37 1998-99 on the management of the Tax File Numbers
Media Releases

Media release: 28 August 2000

TAX OFFICE AGAIN TOLD - PERFORM BETTER

Major shortcomings in the Tax File Number (TFN) system, including problems with data and systems quality and a failure by the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) to strategically manage its own system, are key issues featured in the report, Numbers on the Run, released today, Monday 28 August 2000, by the House of Representatives Economics Committee.

'The starting point for this inquiry into the management of Tax File Numbers was the Auditor-General's finding that $460 million in revenue was not being collected by the Tax Office,' House Economics Committee Chairman, David Hawker, explained. 'The weaknesses and inefficiencies we found in the Tax Office system, and the flow-on effects to other areas of government administration, make this $460 million a conservative estimate.'

For 15 years the Auditor-General and parliamentary inquiries have found shortcomings in the quality of ATO's data and systems. Numbers on the Run reinforces the significant problems identified in the Auditor-General's 1999 performance audit of the Tax File Number system.

During its inquiry into the management of Tax File Numbers, the House Economics Committee found:

'TFN data and systems are the basic building blocks of our tax revenue system', Mr Hawker said. 'High quality data and systems are crucial to ensuring the integrity of the administration of taxation, income support, superannuation and employment generally. The operation of the Australian Business Number is also dependent on the quality of TFN data and systems. It is vital that the Tax Office focus on getting the TFN basics right.'

The House Economics Committee's report also highlights significant potential for fraud against the tax system and more broadly:

'The Tax Office must ensure it has the capacity to manage these known and emerging risks in order to guarantee the long term integrity of the TFN system,' Mr Hawker added. 'The ATO places significant requirements on individuals to comply with tax rules. In return, the Tax Office has an obligation to ensure a high quality system that treats people fairly and in which the government and the community can have confidence'.

'The 26 recommendations featured in Numbers on the Run are aimed at ensuring there is ongoing quality and effective management of the Tax File Number system. Australians should be able to feel confident in the Tax Office, therefore the ATO must give a higher priority to TFN resourcing and policy development by having sufficient staff and resources to effectively manage its TFN system'.

 

MEDIA CONFERENCE
Monday 28 August, 1:30-2pm [after tabling]
Committee Room 2R2, Parliament House, Canberra
Copies of the report will be available from 12:50pm in the Media Conference Venue

 

Further information:
David Hawker MP (Chairman)       02 - 6277 4837 (Parliament House)
Melissa Stutsel (Principal Research Officer)      02 - 6277 4587
Sally Webster, House of Representatives Media Adviser, 02 6277 2063 or 0401 143 724

For background information on the Tax File Number inquiry and a copy of Numbers on the Run see:

Internet: (http://www.aph.gov.au/house/committee/efpa/TFNaudit/report.htm) or
Contact the Committee Secretariat at:
Tel: 02 6277 4587
Fax: 02 6277 4774
Committee E-mail: EFPA.Reps@aph.gov.au
Email: EFPA.Reps@aph.gov.au

 

Committee Membership 39th Parliament

Chairman: Mr David Hawker MP
Deputy Chairman: Ms A Burke MP
Members:
Mr Anthony Albanese MP
Ms Teresa Gambaro MP
Mrs Kay Hull MP
Mr Mark Latham MP
Mr Christopher Pyne MP
Hon Alex Somlyay MP
Dr Andrew Southcott MP

 

TABLING SPEECH: DAVID HAWKER MP, CHAIRMAN

Mr Speaker, this report of the House Economics Committee examines the administration of the Tax File Number system.

The Tax File Number system plays a major role across government in ensuring good public administration. In 1997-98 it contributed to the collection of over $110 billion in tax revenue; helped regulate a superannuation industry with annual contributions of approximately $30 billion and supported the distribution of about $50 billion in Commonwealth benefit payments.

Ensuring the ongoing integrity of the TFN system must be a high priority.

Hence the importance of this inquiry and why the findings are so significant. That is why the findings of our inquiry are so significant. We found major shortcomings in the TFN system, including problems with data and systems quality and a failure by the ATO to strategically manage the system.

The impression that emerged from this inquiry is of an organisation that is reactive rather than proactive; where emphasis is placed on strategies that return a short term financial gain rather than ensuring the long term integrity of the system; and where management philosophies and planning are not well translated through the organisation.

Our report reinforces the significant problems identified in the Auditor-General's 1999 performance audit of the TFN system. It adds to 15 years of Auditor-General and parliamentary inquiries that have found shortcomings in the quality of ATO's data and systems.

While the ATO has acknowledged these problems, we do not believe that they have taken sufficient action to address these ongoing concerns.

For example, the Committee does not consider that the ATO has adequately explained the reasons for the large number of duplicate and excess TFNs, including the extra 65,000 potential duplicates found during this inquiry. This is the third report in ten months to hear evidence of the fraudulent use of TFNs, particularly as part of illegal work by non-residents. We do not consider that the ATO has ruled out the possibility that these known surplus TFNs are being used to commit fraud.

The Committee also found ATO data and systems management lacking when we compared it to other government agencies.

For example, in relation to archiving, Centrelink, the Australian Electoral Commission and the Health Insurance Commission all archive inactive electronic records as part of their data management system - a practice which the ANAO considers to be better practice records management. Yet the ATO claims this is too expensive and so has not archived since the late 1980s.

Again, in the area of recording deceased tax payers, the ATO's performance falls significantly behind other agencies. In this case, the Australian Electoral Commission has made use of information on recorded deaths since the turn of the century, and Centrelink has been matching against Fact of Death data for several years. The ATO have acknowledged the benefits that using this information will have for the quality of TFN data and have been receiving Fact of Death data since April 1999. Yet 12 months later, in April this year, they had still not managed to make the systems changes required to actually use this information.

The Committee has made a series of detailed recommendations in the areas of data and systems quality, data matching and TFN registration. The primary aim of these recommendations is to ensure the ongoing integrity of the TFN system. If implemented, these recommendations will improve the quality of information on which decisions are based, assist in reducing fraud and will also contribute to improving taxpayer service. The recommendations will also have benefits for the other areas of government administration that rely on the TFN system.

Our report also highlights significant potential for fraud against the tax system, and more broadly. In particular, we looked at the growing problems of illegal work by non-residents and identity fraud.

The current taxation system provides significant incentive and opportunity for fraud by non-residents. The tax system provides a range of concessions and penalties to non-residents in different circumstances. Non-residents pay higher tax than residents on income earnt from work and yet pay a lower rate of tax on investments such as bank accounts. The system is further complicated by the fact that there is no close correlation between visa types issued, tax treatment and the need to obtain a TFN. Added to this is a system of self-assessment, where the check on residency status is a box that is ticked on a tax return; and anecdotal evidence that TFNs are available from youth hostels and for sale.

The problems of identity fraud and theft in relation to the use of Tax File Numbers and more broadly was raised by financial institutions, government agencies including law enforcement agencies, and individuals. Anecdotal evidence suggested that false documents can be easily obtained and used. The Committee heard that 1 in 4 frauds reported to the Australian Federal Police involve the assumption of false identities. We also heard about a pilot study conducted by Westpac and the NSW Registry of Births, Deaths and Marriages that found that 13% of birth certificates presented to the bank were false.

Our recommendations in both of these areas emphasise the need for the ATO to get a better handle on the extent of the problem. They also focus on the need for cooperation across the relevant agencies in each area in order to manage these known and emerging risks.

This report draws on advice and opinions from a range of members of the public and experts who participated in the inquiry. I thank these people for their contributions.

I also thank the ANAO for the significant support and advice that they provided during this inquiry. The professionalism and cooperation of the ANAO officers who were involved reflects well on their organisation.

The Committee appreciates the cooperation that we received from the ATO during the inquiry.

I would also like to thank all the members of the Committee and the Committee secretariat for their contributions to this inquiry and report.

The ongoing quality and coverage of the TFN system is important for the administration of taxation, income support, superannuation and employment. The importance of the TFN system for Commonwealth administration must be properly reflected in ATO decision making. The ATO must ensure that the TFN system is one that treats people fairly and in which government and the community can have confidence.

I commend the report to the House.

Back to top

We acknowledge the traditional owners and custodians of country throughout Australia and acknowledge their continuing connection to land, waters and community. We pay our respects to the people, the cultures and the elders past, present and emerging.

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people are advised that this website may contain images and voices of deceased people.