APPENDIX 1


APPENDIX 1

Submissions Received

Submission
Number               Submitter

1. Tony Kennedy
2. Tammy Mc Gaw
3. Maia Cowell
4. Louise Floyd
5. Jacqueline Mills
6. Barbara Rendell
7. Colleen McKenney
8. Lyn Karman
9. Cindy Collins
10. Ryan Flanagan
11. Caitlin Harvey
12. Jaydee Govias
13. Deanne Ogilvie
14. Robyn Dunlop
15. Julie Dolan
16. Amanda O'Neill
17. Genevieve Jeffreys
18. Jenni Wyrsta
19. G Bremmer
20. Susan Kulka
21. Sara Sweet
22. David Michael
23. Gwen Nyman
24. Lyndsay Doyle
25. Rochelle Downing
26. Heather Jones
27. Francesca Reid
28. Ashley Wyatt
29. Sarah Tilley
30. Ella McNamara
31. Kim Coffey
32. Judy Smith
33. Janeen Evans
34. Rod Botica
35. Helena Martin
36. Carol Rainbird
37. Mary Thompkins
38. Rachael Riley
39. Gillian Dent
40. Lyndel Thomas
41. Valerie Flynn
42. Lisa Ashby
43. Lian Staben
44. Helen Kozicka
45. Caroline Raward
46. Genevieve Davey
47. Judi Storer
48. University Veterinary Teaching Hospital - Sydney
49. Lisa Ackerman, BVSc (Hons)
50. George and Marela Vuckov
51. Su  Ferreira
52. Debra Agland
53. Malcolm McCoull
54. Sue Turner
55. Wendy Clarke
56. Amanda Sharma
57. Deborah Favier
58. Janice Witon
59. Christine Yurovich
60. Gwen Ferry
61. Lynn Adderson
62. Penny Floyd
63. Leonie McLeod
64. Claire Burnet
65. Isabel Bryce
66. Maria Pulkkinen
67. Pam Oates
68. Vilia Marcelline
69. Queensland Halal Certification Service
70. Julia Berney
71. C Needham
72. Sophia Pegiou
73. Lynne Foley
74. Simone Bowskill
75. David and Jenny James
76. Julie Kmet
77. David Barns
78. Renate Homburg
79. Nicole Masters
80. Vanna Walsh
81. Janet Collinson
82. Jo Hobson
83. Mckay Family
84. Carol Vincent
85. Phil Moody
86. Nigel Brothers and Catherine Bone
87. Judy Dangerfield
88. Rachel Cassidy
89. Lara Dangerfield and Maurine Bone
90. Madalena Grobbelaar
91. Robert and Monique McGregor
92. Howard and Lorraine Ford
93. Lynda Yates
94. Murray Nixon
95. Kim Collins
96. Jan Myers
97. Penny Marks
98. Carol Kenneally
99. Marius Grobbelaar
100. Tracey Stewart
101. Mick Murray MLA, WA State Member for Collie-Preston; WA State Shadow Minister for Agriculture, Forestry, Racing and Gaming, South West
102. John Pugh
103. Tracey Fraser
104. Barristers Animal Welfare Panel
105. World Society for the Protection of Animals
106. Elaine  Hunt
107. Animal Liberation ACT
108. Maureen Payne
109. AASMB
110. Ron and Jeneve Barnicoat
111. Adriana Wall
112. Stuart Austin
113. Patricia Pengilly
114. Linda Fleeman
115. Patricia Ley
116. Lucinda Smyth
117. Tony Hayne
118. Cattle Council of Australia
119. Juliana Harmsen
120. Chantal Teague
121. Stop Live Exports
122. Barry Hoare
123. Jessica Sackmann
124. Rachel Westcott
125. Naomi Oliver
126. Michelle  Cusworth
127. Tiffany Keele
128. Larry Graham
129. Renee Blight-Clark
130. Tania Cummings
131. Kelsey Neilson
132. Mandy  Swann
133. Kelva Hughes
134. Susan Foster
135. Eric Britton
136. Tanya Mulholland
137. Annaliese Dowling
138. Linda Campbell
139. Kathryn Woolfe
140. Casey Johnson
141. Raymond Bromley
142. Sharon Rabusin
143. Kathryn Keen
144. Shire of DerbyWest Kimberley
145. Jennifer Miller
146. Lydia Du Rieu
147. Mary Barton
148. Goat Industry Council of Australia
149. Paul MacLeman
150. Melissa Knoll
151. Graeme Simpson
152. Michael Trant
153. Carolyn Wassell
154. Risti Permani
155. Annarosa Berman
156. Claire Morgan
157. Paul  McGreevy
158. Carolyn Cooper
159. Danica Brooks
160. Mr Jim and Mrs Pam McGregor
161. Jennifer Hughes
162. Davis Charles
163. Aliya Hutchison
164. Sherri Brazear
165. Iris Toren
166. Ray Trewin
167. Naomi Annear
168. Charlie Schroeder
169. Albert Mah
170. Belle Gibbons
171. Jennifer Spencer
172. Lorraine  McGinnis
173. Miranda Webster
174. George Palmer and Susan Goadby
175. Voiceless
176. Fraser Paterson
177. Colleen Curlewis
178. Mark Chambers
179. Community and Public Sector Union (CPSU)
180. Martha Goodhue
181. Christine  Collier-Harris
182. Linda Bogdanovs
183. Jennifer Macdougall
184. robert wansbrough
185. Gigi Robertson
186. Raelene Trenaman
187. Peter Hatch
188. Raelene Hall
189. Julie Hardaker (Cooke)
190. Rosaria  Hughes
191. Tracey Paterson
192. Shannon Vassos
193. AgForce Queensland
194. Pastoralists and Graziers Association of WA Inc. (PGAWA)
195. L and A Bailey
196. Anne Greenaway
197. Australian Beef Association (ABA)
198. University of Adelaide
199. The Australian Merino Society Inc
200. Elizabeth Hussain
201. Romy Klooger
202. Louise Gourlay
203. Marion Bulloch
204. David Warriner
205. G Weetman
206. Consolidated Pastoral Company Pty Ltd
207. Ann McMaster
208. David Beard
209. Belinda Alcorn
210. Peter Edwards
211. Lena Bodin
212. Australian Federation of Islamic Societies Inc (AFIS)
213. Compassion in World Farming
214. Jan Kendall
215. Barry Thomson
216. Sonya Prinsloo
217. Lucinda Smyth
218. Tom Toren
219. Keith Leung
220. Thomas Moore
221. David Steadman
222. Tony Phillips
223. Lyn Copas
224. Jacqueline Curley
225. Jenny Deveraux
226. Jo-Anne Bloomfield
227. Stop Tasmania Animal Cruelty
228. Peter Kerkenezov
229. Suzanne Dixon
230. Sally Witherspoon
231. Warringal Conservation Society (WCS)
232. Terrie Templeton
233. Branko Rasic
234. Linda Stratford
235. Neale Blackwood
236. Carol Slater
237. Ismail Fredericks
238. Sandra Sims
239. Imraan Bergman
240. Judith McKinnon
241. Norm Eather
242. David Jasper
243. Marta Mendiolaza
244. Lisa Stevens
245. Australian Muslim Animal Welfare Association NSW
246. Catherine Deb
247. Diane Mangan
248. Carolyn Frank
249. Wollongong Islamic Society
250. Australian Muslim Animal Welfare Association Queensland and Northern Territory
251. Tanya Baker
252. UNALLOCATED
253. Carol Richard
254. Nikoleta Minns
255. South Australian Farmers Federation (SAFF)
256. Clare Sunderland
257. HKM Global
258. Ann Beeke
259. Robert and Vicki Beard
260. Michael Harrison
261. Karen Hansen
262. Anthony Fels
263. People Against Live Exports and Intensive Farming (PALE)
264. Simon Emmott
265. Di Johnstone
266. Bonalbo Cattle Company PL
267. Narelle Ryan
268. Lyn Slade
269. Australians Supporting Beef Farmers (ASBF) Ltd
270. John Underwood AM
271. Terry Underwood OAM
272. Brett Cattle Company PL
273. Yvonne Darcy
274. Linda Boyd
275. Shelley Male
276. Northern Rivers Community Legal Centre
277. John Arlaud
278. Patricia Petersen
279. Humane Society International (HSI)
280. Debra Henderson
281. Australian Veterinary Association (AVA)
282. Faculty of Veterinary Science, University of Melbourne
283. Lawrence Leung
284. Narissa Leung
285. Patricia Warren
286. Golda Mangan
287. Karina Leung
288. John Joyce
289. Conservation Council of South Australia
290. Australasian Meat Industry Employees Union (Qld. Branch)
291. Avriel Tyson
292. Deborah Clift
293. Linda Leslie
294. Roger Hinkley
295. Louise Bonomi
296. Sentient (The Veterinary Institute for Animal Ethics)
297. Julie Lewin
298. Edgar's Mission Farm Sanctuary
299. Western Australian Beef Council
300. Kylie Miller
301. Michael Cox
302. Maree Connor
303. Eric Roberts
304. Curtis Miller
305. Antje Struthmann
306. Wellard Group Holdings
307. Hayley Anderson-Higginson
308. Kieren Henderson
309. Moses Silver
310. Katherine Phan
311. Anthony Houghton
312. Emilianne Krause
313. Anthony Haynes
314. Rosemary Sullivan
315. Meat and Livestock Australia
316. Patricia Gretton
317. Katherine Town Council
318. Central Desert Shire Council
319. Raelene Govett
320. Julene  Haack
321. Elizebeth Flower
322. Ian Yeates
323. Australian Livestock Export Corporation Limited
324. Livestock and Rural Transport Association of WA
325. Deborah Brackenreg and Tracey Farrar
326. Animals Australia
327. Leonnie Harrington
328. Leslie Thiele
329. Sue Teakle
330. Gary Verri
331. Susan Smith
332. Carole de Fraga
333. RSPCA Australia
334. Tony Crook MP, Member for O'Connor
335. Wally Mitchell
336. Marie Muldoon
337. Jim and Barbara Sullivan
338. Eion McAllister
339. Heather Gibb
340. Gogo Station PL
341. Lorraine Fox
342. Robert Steel
343. Margaret Clinch
344. John Armstrong
345. National Farmers' Federation (NFF)
346. Australian Meat Industry Council (AMIC)
347. Halal Certification Authority Australia (HCAA)
348. Tom Stockwell
349. Barkly Shire Council
350. Local Government Association of the NT
351. Coodardie Brahmans
352. Grant Brooks
353. Gehan Jayawardhana
354. Virginia Sullivan
355. UNALLOCATED
356. Northern Territory Agricultural Association (NTAA)
357. Roper Gulf Shire Council
358. The Western Australian Farmers Federation (Inc.) (WAFarmers)
359. Hayfield Shenandoah, APN Pty Ltd
360. Victorian Farmers Federation Livestock Group
361. Sheepmeat Council of Australia
362. Townsend Cattle Company
363. Rashida Khan
364. Jo Maguire
365. Clair O'Brien
366. Allen Crisell
367. Margie West
368. Western Australian Government Department of Agriculture and Food
369. UNALLOCATED
370. Robyn Chalklen
371. Alison Boulton
372. Gaye Crawford
373. Lois Pavy and Bruce Fletcher
374. Sandra Rieck
375. Pamela Wren
376. Southern Cross University Animal Law Club
377. Carolin Thomas
378. Philippa Sheperd
379. Terina McDonald
380. Loani Burns
381. Kasey Pennell
382. Tasmanian Farmers and Graziers Association (TFGA)
383. Rhonda Carroll
384. Katherine Luke
385. Myli Kumar
386. Che Wall
387. Wendy Lewthwaite
388. Pamela   Gillot
389. Francesca De Biase
390. Kaylene McIntosh
391. J R Percy
392. Tanya Barker
393. Nicole Fahey
394. Annette Angell
395. Sarah Dye
396. Donna Perkins
397. Oakvale Brahman Stud
398. Glenys Lawton
399. Suzanne Lawton-Clark
400. Cheryl Forrest-Smith
401. David Stoate
402. David Griffiths
403. Australian Livestock and Rural Transporters Association (ALTRA)
404. Australian Livestock Exporters' Council (ALEC)
405. Yanina Wojcik
406. Jean Robins
407. Markus Rathsmann
408. Pro Bono Animal Law Service
409. AMAWA
410. Cherie Collins
411. Temple Grandin
412. Rohan Teakle
413. NSW Farmers Association
414. NT Cattlemen's Association
415. Louise Conte
416. Northern Territory Government
417. Australian Woolgrowers Association
418. Christine  Glenn
419. Abdul Ayan
420. Lynn MacLaren
421. Sandy Presland
422. Broome Port Authority
423. Gerald Baker
424. Sarah  Buckley
425. APN Pty Ltd, Shenandoah
426. Australian Meat Producers Group
427. Christine Lawton
428. Gary Stewart
429. Broome Chamber of Commerce Inc.

 

Additional Information Received

  • Received on 17 August 2011, from Mr Don Heatley MLA.  Copy of opening statement from public hearing on 4 August 2011 in Darwin, NT;
  • Received on 19 August 2011, from the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry (DAFF).  Answers to questions taken on notice on 10 August 2011 in Canberra, ACT;
  • Received on 22 August 2011, from the Australasian Meat Industry Employees Union (AMIEU).  Answers to questions taken on notice on 10 August 2011 in Canberra, ACT
  • Received on 9 September 2011, from Northern Territory Agricultural Association (NTAA).  Answers to questions taken on notice on 2 September 2011 in Katherine, NT;
  • Received on 13 September 2011, from the World Society for the Protection of Animals (WSPA).  Answers to questions taken on notice on 10 August 2011 in Canberra, ACT;
  • Received on 13 September 2011, from Ms Val Dyer.  Answers to questions taken on notice on 2 September 2011 in Katherine, NT;
  • Received on 13 September 2011, from Dr Conall O'Connell, Secretary, Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry (DAFF).  Answers to written questions on notice from the committee on 9 September 2011;
  • Received on 14 September 2011, from the Australian Livestock Exporters Council (ALEC).  Answers to questions taken on notice on 4 August 2011 in Canberra, ACT;
  • Received on 14 September 2011, from Animals Australia.  Answers to questions taken on notice on 10 August 2011 in Canberra, ACT;
  • Received on 14 September 2011, from the RSPCA.  Answers to questions taken on notice on 10 August 2011 in Canberra, ACT;
  • Received on 15 September 2011, from Ms Cynthia Bakalian.  Answers to questions taken on notice on 2 September 2011 in Katherine, NT;
  • Received on 15 & 27 September 2011, from Four Corners program, Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC).  Answers to questions taken on notice on 14 September 2011 in Canberra, ACT;
  • Received on 15 September 2011, from Professor Ivan Caple.  Additional information regarding submission following public hearing on 14 September 2011 in Canberra, ACT;
  • Received on 16 September 2011, from the Pastoralists and Graziers Association of Western Australia (PGA WA).  Answers to questions taken on notice on 1 September 2011 in Broome, WA;
  • Received on 16 September 2011, from Mr Michael Thompson, Munda Station, Port Hedland, WA.  Information on compensation payments for producers requested during the public hearing on 1 September 2011 in Broome, WA;
  • Received on 20 September 2011, from Ms Kirsty Forshaw, Nita Downs Station. Information on compensation payments for producers requested during the public hearing on 1 September 2011 in Broome, WA;
  • Received on 22 September 2011, from the Hon. Terry Redman, WA Minister for Agriculture, Food, Forestry and Corrective Services.  Answers to questions taken on notice on 1 September 2011 in Broome, WA;
  • Received on 27 September 2011, from LiveCorp.  Answers to questions taken on notice on 14 September 2011 in Canberra, ACT;
  • Received on 27 September 2011, from Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry (DAFF).  Answers to questions taken on notice on 14 September 2011 in Canberra, ACT;
  • Received on 28 September 2011, from Ms Jo Evans, Acting Deputy Secretary, Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry (DAFF).  Correction to evidence provided to committee on 14 September 2011 in Canberra, ACT;
  • Received on 5 October 2011, from Meat and Livestock Australia (MLA).  Answers to questions taken on notice on 20 September 2011 in Canberra, ACT;
  • Received on 26 October 2011, from Mr Mark Scott, Managing Director, Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC).  Response to letter from the Chair regarding evidence given at a public hearing on 14 September 2011.  Original letter from Chair included.

 

TABLED DOCUMENTS

  • 4 August 2011, Darwin, NT:
    • Tabled by Mr Luke Bowen, Northern Territory Cattleman's Association.  Maps of Northern Territory Pastoral Leases.
  • 10 August 2011, Canberra, ACT:
    • Tabled by Ms Heather Neil, RSPCA.  'The slaughter of Australian Cattle in Indonesia: an Observational Study' report by Dr Bidda Jones, RSPCA Australia, 2011;
    • Tabled by Senator Sean Edwards.  'Livestock Mortalities for Exports by Sea' tables for Cattle, Buffalo, Sheep and Goat Export Voyages 2000 – 2010;
    • Tabled by Mr Lee Norris, Australasian Meat Industry Employees Union.
      • 'Benchmarking the Beef Supply Chain in Eastern Indonesia' flow chart and tables document;
      • Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research, 'Final Report: Benchmarking the Beef Supply Chain in Eastern Indonesia';
    • Tabled by Senator Chris Back.  'Live cattle export as a percentage of turn off' graph;
    • Tabled by the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry.  Opening statement.
  • Tabled by Senator Chris Back subsequent to public hearing on 10 August 2011 in Canberra, ACT.  Statement letter signed by Mr Ali Aman in Indonesia and English translation regarding cattle slaughter in PRH Binjai.
  • 1 September 2011, Broome, WA:
    • Tabled by Mr Andrew Stewart, Landmark.  Opening statement;
    • Tabled by Ms Elsia Archer, Shire of Derby/West Kimberley.
      • Copy of email dated 27 June 2011, from Mr Shane Burge, CEO, Derby/West Kimberley Shire to Mr Gary Gray – subject Live Cattle Exports and Shire Rates;
      • Council Paper written by Ms Janet Takarangi, Economic Development Officer, dated July 2011, titled Examining the potential economic impact on the East Kimberley economy of the halting of live cattle exports to Indonesia;
      • Copy of Shire of Derby/West Kimberley submission to the Independent Livestock Export Review;
    • Tabled by Mr Phillip Hams.  Copy of Cummings Economics Report dated December 2009, RefJ2247, titled Upgrading the Tanami Road: Economic Impact Statement.
  • 2 September 2011, Katherine, NT:
    • Tabled by Ms Jo-Anne Bloomfield, Hodgson River Station.  Four photographs on two pages (Bloomfield Trust – Steers 27.08.11);
    • Tabled by Mr Marcus Rathsman and Mr Gehan Jayawhardna.  Four photographs of livestock box;
    • Tabled by Mr John Armstrong, Gilnockie Station.
      • Extract from Manual of yard plans for South East Asian abattoirs – pages i, iii, 1, 2 and 3;
      • Meat and Livestock Australia/Livecorp publication dated October 2004, Manual for cattle slaughter restraining box – Revised Mark 1 and Mark 2 boxes;
      • Meat and Livestock Australia/Livecorp publication, dated June 2006, titled Manual of yard plans for South-East Asian abattoirs- [includes DVD marked "1. Drawings and images from Manual of yard plans for South-East Asian abattoirs, June 2006 and 2. Manual for cattle slaughter restraint box, revised;
      • Opening statement.
  • 14 September 2011, Canberra, ACT:
    • Tabled by the Sheepmeat Council of Australia.  Opening statement;
    • Tabled by Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry.  Opening statement.
  • 20 September 2011, Canberra, ACT:
    • Tabled by Senator Matt Thistlethwaite.  Copy of a letter, dated 6 May 2011, from Mr Cameron McDonald, Animal Welfare Manager Indonesia, Meat & Livestock Australia.

Navigation: Previous Page | Contents | Next Page