House of Representatives Committees

Contents

Foreword
Membership of the Committee
Terms of Reference
List of Abbreviations
List of Recommendations
Chapter 1 Introduction
Chapter 2 Innovation and Commercialisation—Concepts, Definitions and Metrics
Chapter 3 Innovation and Commercialisation Policy and Program Framework
Chapter 4 Human Capital—Knowledge and Skills
Chapter 5 Connecting Knowledge, People and Markets
Chapter 6 Life Cycle Support and Funding for Innovation and Commercialisation
Appendix A—List of submissions
Appendix B—List of Exhibits
Appendix C—List of Hearings and Witnesses
Appendix D—Australian Government’s Funding Commitment to Backing Australia’s Ability
Appendix E—Summary of Government Innovation/Commercialisation Programs

Foreword

When the Committee undertook to inquire into pathways to technological innovation, it sought to bring together a series of successful case studies and look at the obstacles faced in commercialising research, with a view to making recommendations on fine-tuning Government policies to support innovation. The intention was to consider the impediments that these successful innovators overcame on the path to commercialisation.

However, from discussions with researchers and entrepreneurs and from reading the case studies submitted to the inquiry, it became apparent this approach would only provide part of the picture.

Many successful innovators experienced a smooth pathway to developing their product and finding markets. These are the success stories and they are documented in other publications such as the 2005 report of the Prime Minister’s Science Engineering and Innovation Council Working Group, Growing Technology‑Based SMEs. These stories are heartening and affirm the calibre of Australian innovation and the strength of some aspects of the Government’s innovation support framework.

In addition to these positive case studies though, submissions were made illuminating a range of issues which might impact on the path from technological innovation to commercialisation. From this evidence, a number of difficulties were identified and the Committee heard a different set of stories about innovation that is hampered because of gaps in the innovation support system.

It is apparent from this range of evidence, and the two sets of stories, that some pathways to innovation are well developed and relatively smooth for the Australian entrepreneur or innovating business or research institution. Other pathways are, however, less well formed and the Committee has focussed on the consensus issues from those seeking to innovate in Australia.

Drawing on the consensus issues raised in the evidence to the Committee, the report makes recommendations about improving linkages and collaborations between the public and private sectors, fostering a more entrepreneurial culture in Australia, and better publicising the range of innovation assistance available.

Other recommendations relate to addressing gaps in the assistance available and removing blocks to innovation— access to start-up funding and later stage commercialisation activities such as marketing; proof of concept funding; cultural, promotional and structural issues which may discourage academics from the commercialisation path; and Government procurement policies.

The recommendations are the result of extensive evidence and discussions with a wide range of industries, Government departments, universities and research agencies, peak bodies and individuals with experience in innovation. I thank those who contributed to the inquiry and those who allowed the Committee to visit their premises and see firsthand many of the processes of innovation. At times the inquiry took members of the Committee into technical scientific areas and I thank my colleagues for their dedication to the issues and commitment to grappling with the complexities of innovation. I also thank the Secretariat for its work on venture capital and other specialised areas of tax and corporations law.

Today innovation is recognised as the multitude of pathways that encompass all types of basic research, new technologies and improvements in business processes, from their initiation through to commercialisation or community uptake. Innovation is also recognised as vital to Australia’s economic future as it is a means of impacting on long-run economic growth, improving health and social well-being, and addressing environmental threats.

The Committee commends the substantial Australian Government investment made to innovation through Backing Australia’s Ability ($3 billion from 2001 to 2006, and an additional $8.3 billion from 2006 to 2011), and recent announcements in the 2006–07 Budget which boost the opportunities for venture capitalists at the early stage of commercialisation, and inject new life into the National Health and Medical Research Council. Given the importance of innovation to Australia’s long‑run economic performance, there is however always room for improvement.

This report seeks to make a contribution to building a nation that values innovation, addressing gaps in innovation support and removing impediments which may stifle innovation. Through implementation of the recommendations of this report, the Committee hopes that some pathways to technological innovation will be made easier, thereby strengthening Australia’s pathway to increased growth and global competitiveness.

I hope that this report will encourage a broader look at the overall balance of Australia’s innovation policy, including issues such as the focus on research intensive R&D. In addition, I hope that policy makers and economists will consider the metrics needed to measure ‘successful’ innovation, including a broader view of what ‘success’ may mean given the multitude of pathways and outcomes that innovation now embraces.

Mr Petro Georgiou MP

Chair

Membership of the Committee

Chair

Mr Petro Georgiou MP

 

Deputy Chair

Mr Harry Quick MP

 

Members

Mr Anthony Byrne MP

(to 10 May 2005)

 

 

Mr Chris Hayes MP

(from 11 May 2005)

 

 

Mr Harry Jenkins MP

 

 

Dr Dennis Jensen MP

 

 

The Hon Jackie Kelly MP

 

 

The Hon Roger Price MP

 

 

Mr David Tollner MP

 

 

The Hon Danna Vale MP

 

 

Dr Mal Washer MP

 

Committee Secretariat

Secretary

Dr Anna Dacre

Inquiry Secretary

Dr Alison Clegg

Research Officers

Dr Lea Hill

Ms Rachelle Mitchell

Administrative Officers

Ms Emma Martin

Mr Danny Miletic

Terms of Reference

The House of Representatives Standing Committee on Science and Innovation is to inquire into Australian technological innovation and pathways to commercialisation, with particular reference to examples of successful Australian technological innovations that demonstrate strategies to overcome potential impediments and factors determining success.

Innovation is the path of conceiving, developing and implementing ideas through to the generation of products, process and services. It gives economic value to a nation’s knowledge.

To assist in its inquiry, the Committee seeks to compile a series of case studies of successful technological innovations, and the pathways to commercialisation. Submissions are sought detailing successful examples of Australian technological innovations. Submissions are also sought with particular reference to successful innovations, on issues such as:


List of abbreviations

ABF

Australian Business Foundation

ABS

Australian Bureau of Statistics

ACDS

Australian Council of Deans of Science

ACIP

Advisory Council on Intellectual Property

ACS

Australian Computer Society Inc

AEEMA

Australian Electrical and Electronic Manufacturers’ Association

AFC

Australian Film Commission

AFTRS

Australian Film, Television and Radio School

AGC

Australian Geoscience Council

AGP

Australian Growth Partnerships

AIA

Australian Innovation Association

AIC

Australian Institute for Commercialisation

AIG

Australian Industry Group

AIIA

Australian Information Industry Association

AIMS

Australian Institute of Marine Science

ANSTO

Australian Nuclear Science and Technology Organisation

ANTA

Australian National Training Authority

ANZAAS

Australian and New Zealand Association for the Advancement of Science

ARC

Australian Research Council

ATO

Australian Taxation Office

ATSE

Australian Academy of Technological Sciences and Engineering

AVCC

Australian Vice-Chancellors’ Committee

BAA

Backing Australia’s Ability

BCA

Business Council of Australia

BERD

Business Expenditure on Research and Development

BIF

Biotechnology Innovation Fund

BIHECC

Business–Industry–Higher Education Collaboration Council

CASR

Collaboration and Structural Reform(Fund)

CCST

Coordinating Committee on Science and Technology

CHASS

Council for Humanities, Arts and Social Sciences

COMET

Commercialising Emerging Technologies

CRC

Cooperative Research Centre

CRP

Commercial Ready Program

CSIRO

Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation

DCITA

(Australian Government) Department of Communications, Information Technology and the Arts

DEST

(Australian Government) Department of Education, Science and Training

DITR

(Australian Government) Department of Industry, Tourism and Resources

DSTO

(Australian Government) Defence Science and Technology Organisation

EMDG

Export Market Development Grant

ESVCLP

Early Stage Venture Capital Limited Partnerships

EU

European Union

FMA

Financial Management Accountability (Act 1997)

GEM

Global Entrepreneurship Monitor

GDP

Gross Domestic Product

HECS

Higher Education Contribution Scheme

HEFCE

Higher Education Funding Council for England ( UK)

HEIF

Higher Education Innovation Fund ( UK)

HEROBC

Higher Education Reach Out for Business and Community (Scheme)

ICGS

Integrated Company Growth Services

ICIP

Industry Cooperative Innovation Program

ICT

Information and Communications Technology

IGS

Institutional Grants Scheme

IIF

Innovation Investment Fund

IP

Intellectual Property

IR&D

Industry Research and Development

ISIC

International Standard Industrial Classification

KCA

Knowledge Commercialisation Australasia

MBA

Masters of Business Administration

MLA

Meat and Livestock Australia

MRI

Medical Research Institute

NCGP

National Competitive Grants Program

NCP

National Competition Policy

NCVER

National Centre for Vocational Education Research

NHMRC

National Health and Medical Research Council

NIAS

National Innovation Awareness Strategy

NIC

National Innovation Council

NIQTL

National Institute of Quality Teaching and Leadership

NRP

National Research Priority

OECD

Organisation of Economic Cooperation and Development

PCT

Patent Cooperation Treaty

PDF

Pooled Development Funds

PFRA

Publicly Funded Research Agencies

PFRI

Publicly Funded Research Institutes

PMSEIC

Prime Minister’s Science, Engineering and Innovation Council

PSF

Pre-Seed Fund

R&D

Research and Development

RDC

Rural Research and Development Corporation Chairs Committee

ROI

Return on Investment

RQF

Research Quality Framework

RTS

Research Training Scholarships

SBEP

Small Business Entrepreneurship Program

SBIR

Small Business Innovation Research ( USA)

SET

Scientific, Engineering and Technical

SIA

Science Industry Australia

SME

Small to Medium Enterprise

TPP

Technological Product and Process Innovation

TRIPS

Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Agreement

UK

United Kingdom

US(A)

United States of America

VCLP

Venture Capital Limited Partnership

VET

Vocational Education and Training

WIPO

World Intellectual Property Organisation

 

List of recommendations

3 Innovation and Commercialisation Policy and Program Framework

Recommendation 1

The Committee recommends that the Australian Government better promote the assistance that is available for businesses to locate the most appropriate innovation support programs.

Increased promotion to be considered includes:

Recommendation 2

The Committee recommends that the Australian Government Department of Education, Science and Training establish a working group to improve the coordination of Australia’s innovation policy framework.

Specifically the working group should consider initiatives to:

4 Human Capital—Knowledge and Skills

Recommendation 3

The Committee recommends that the Department of Education, Science and Training, in conjunction with the Australian Vice-Chancellors’ Committee and publicly funded research agencies:

Recommendation 4

The Committee recommends that the Department of Education, Science and Training expand its annual Australian Science and Innovation System: A Statistical Snapshot to include the following data:

Recommendation 5

The Committee recommends that the Australian Government establish a dedicated whole-of-government taskforce to develop a series of measures targeting the early development of entrepreneurial skills in the education system (including the early school years) and the broader community. To inform the development of these measures, the Committee recommends that the taskforce draw upon the expertise of educators, researchers and industry specialists.

5 Connecting Knowledge, People and Markets

Recommendation 6

The Committee recommends that IP Australia implement strategies to promote the uptake of the innovation patent, and report to the Australian Government Minister for Industry by 30 June 2007 on the following:

Recommendation 7

The Committee recommends that the Attorney-General request the Advisory Council on Intellectual Property to review Australia’s intellectual property system to determine the capacity for reduction in the misuse of the system.

Recommendation 8

The Committee recommends that the Australian Government, through the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, pursue the enforcement of intellectual property legislation during trade and diplomatic negotiations with China.

Recommendation 9

The Committee recommends that the Australian Government review Intellectual Property legislation according to National Competition Policy Agreements and establish an Intellectual Property legislation system of periodic re-review.

Recommendation 10

The Committee recommends that the Australian Government give priority consideration to the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation’s proposal for an Australian Growth Partnerships program to engage small to medium enterprises in demand driven collaborations with publicly funded research agencies.

Recommendation 11

The Committee recommends that the Australian Government request the Business Industry Higher Education Collaboration Council to examine and develop the business case for third stream funding to universities.

Recommendation 12

The Committee recommends that the Australian Government introduce a funded cluster development program to encourage the Australia-wide development of clusters which bring together innovation in research, business and education.

6 Life Cycle Support and Funding for Innovation and Commercialisation

Recommendation 13

The Committee recommends that the Australian Government introduce a funded proof of concept scheme, based on the Group of Eight Innovation Stimulation Fund proposal and providing the following for university research projects with high potential for commercial outcomes:

Recommendation 14

The Committee recommends that the Australian Government implement additional support mechanisms to specifically assist the progression of innovation through pathways other than the formation of start-up companies.

Recommendation 15

The Committee recommends that the Australian Government assess the revenue implications and potential economic returns of extending the R&D Tax Concessions eligibility to include Australian based subsidiaries of multinational companies.

Recommendation 16

The Committee recommends that the Australian Government Department of Industry, Tourism and Resources extend the support available to provide for later stage commercialisation activities, such as market identification, marketing and sales strategies.

This support may be provided either by extending the range of activities eligible under the Commercial Ready Program or by establishing alternative mechanisms of assistance which are compliant with World Trade Organisation and other trade agreement conditions.

Recommendation 17

The Committee recommends that the Australian Department of Industry, Tourism and Resources conduct a formal review by 30 June 2007 of the effectiveness of the Commercial Ready Program, giving particular consideration to the following possible program amendments:

Recommendation 18

The Committee recommends that the Australian Government:

Print Preliminary Pages (PDF 175KB) < - Report Home  : Chapter 1 - >

Back to top

We acknowledge the traditional owners and custodians of country throughout Australia and acknowledge their continuing connection to land, waters and community. We pay our respects to the people, the cultures and the elders past, present and emerging.

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people are advised that this website may contain images and voices of deceased people.